Well, not so much a review. I’ve only been using the player for a few days - less time than it took for the delivery. Tiger Direct updated my billing address, but not the shipping address, so I needed to phone UPS no less than three times to get the shipment redirected. To criticize Tiger Direct would be a waste of time. I’ve rarely had a purchase from them that went seamlessly, and I had prepared myself in advance for something going wrong.
The reason I chose to buy from them was that they had the best DVD/DivX player for the best price. Brand name, card reader, decent online reviews, and reads DivX movies from DVD-R. That last point is good because you can fit an entire season of a TV series on one disc. It also supports HDMI and I’ve read that it is excellent at upscaling footage to HDTV formats. Two features I won’t be using until my 6/49 investments pan out.
Lately, Simone and I have taken to watching HBO and Showtime TV shows. Since they can take many months to show up on TMN in Canada, we’ve been forced chosen to download them. I realize this is taking ad dollars away from the people who deserve it, but I refuse to play the game while the RIAA, MPAA and the Canadian counterparts are squabbling over distribution rights. Season 2 of Stargate: Atlantis was finished in Canada before half the episodes showed south of the border. It then played all the way through season 3 in the US before even starting broadcast here. It’s petty, but I just can’t forgive them for that.
Since Simone’s laptop isn’t equipped with a video-out (only VGA out) I figured it was worth picking up a proper DivX player in order to watch it on my big screen 27″ CRT with stereo surround sound. I’ve done a test of the player’s compatibility with different file formats, but I’ll be leaving a more comprehensive test for a later time.
One of my favourite features doesn’t even have anything to do with the packaged product. My television is RCA and so is my VCR (yes, I still have it hooked up) and they both use the exact same remote. It’s supposed to be a Universal Remote, but except for one model of digital cable box I’ve never had it work properly with any other devices. The new DVD remote is pretty ugly and the buttons are small - the complete antithesis of all prior RCA remotes.
Luckily, nearly all DVD functions are available and work by default from my old television universal remote. It’s missing the Title Menu function and the skip-chapter button, but everything else is on there. If I do need those other functions then I’ll just grab the fugly remote that was packaged with the player.
I loaded four episodes of Entourage that Simone and I hadn’t seen yet. Two worked, two didn’t. Of the two that didn’t work, one was at a resolution higher than 720×480 and simply wouldn’t display. The other problematic file I suspect was partially corrupted, but I haven’t tested it much.
The player handles .AVI, .DIVX, .MP4 and even .OGM containers for video. It supports multiple languages and subtitles as external text files. The MP4 support seems the most limited, which is unfortunate. I haven’t tested any formal podcasts yet, but I found that the 480×272 PSP-formatted MP4s did not work. It’s not too much of a problem since most shows I watch on my PSP are just transcoded from some other video format.
When you put in a disc with video files instead of a DVD movie (or switch over to the card reader) then a file browser pops up. It looks very pretty, and displays JPEGs as thumbnails when you select them, but there’s not much else nice to say about it. It only supports about 13 characters, so when you burn discs, name your files with this in mind. The original file of “Entourage_S04E05….avi” would only display “ENTOURAGE_S04″. If you have multiple episodes, they would all show as “ENTOURAGE_S04″.
Removing the thumbnail pane would give the interface more space for more letters, but I don’t think that’s relevant. My guess is that this is just a limitation of the player’s firmware. Probably the most disappointing thing about the player.
What I assumed I would be most disappointed with was the load time, or the limited file support. I was happily surprised when I saw that the player loads the disc quickly, and that it even supports OGM, subtitles and multiple audio tracks (something I don’t think is even documented).
I’m calling the player “Murdoch 2.0″. Even though I didn’t build it, the player is a final replacement for my custom-built case I made from an old Pentium 200 with a Sigma Designs Xcard to play back DivX movies on my television. The final product was more complete than the above link shows, but that page was more to test out what CSS can do than show off Murdoch. That project met with limited success, but was mostly a hobby to keep trying new things to turn old, useless computer parts into a machine that could rival the newest Windows Media Centre PCs.
I’ll post more technical mumbo-jumbo later after I document the results of the DivXTest CD.